The name of my blog is (obviously) meant in jest. I always feel a pang of guilt over having chosen it, though, when I think about Rebecca Schaeffer, the young actress who was gunned down in her doorway by a deranged stalker at the tender age of 21 in 1989. My grandma and I religiously watched My Sister Sam, the CBS series she starred on, when it was on the air in the late-80s and were both considerably obsessed. We were equally devastated when it was cancelled after a scant one and a half seasons and then again when we learned of Schaeffer’s murder a little over a year later. While the show and its star have never strayed far from my mind in the years since, somehow I never though about tracking down the supposed San Francisco building where Schaeffer’s teenaged character, Patti Russell, lived with her older sister, Sam Russell (Pam Dawber). Thankfully, in 2013, a reader named Vera Charles left a comment on my 2009 post about downtown L.A.’s Pico House, which I was reporting on due to its use as “Sacramento’s” CBI headquarters on The Mentalist, alerting me to the fact that the very same spot served as the My Sister Sam apartment! I was floored over the news, but, for whatever reason, am only just now getting around to re-blogging about the historic site.
[ad]
Constructed from 1869 to 1870, Pico House has the distinction of being Los Angeles’ first three-story building.
Commissioned by Pio Pico, the last governor of California under Mexican rule, the Italianate structure originally served as an 82-room hotel. Not just any hotel, though – it was the city’s finest, featuring arched windows and doors at every turn, a grand double staircase, an aviary, 21 parlors, 2 courtyards, a French restaurant, restrooms and water closets for both sexes on each floor, a bar, and a billiards room. Designed by architect Ezra F. Kysor, the lodging cost $48,000 to construct and a whopping $34,000 to decorate and furnish. At the time of its opening, the most expensive rooms ran for $3 a night.
Though the property proved bustling throughout its first decade, Pio wasn’t the savviest when it came to finances and he wound up losing Pico House to foreclosure in 1880. The site subsequently passed through several hands, continuing to function as a hotel, before being transformed into an inexpensive boarding house named The National in 1892. It operated as such for the next three decades, growing more dilapidated as time passed. Though the original moniker was restored in 1920, the building continued to deteriorate, becoming a mere shadow of its once grand self, and was eventually condemned in 1922.
It was finally acquired by the city of L.A. in 1953 and incorporated into El Pueblo de Los Angeles State Historic Monument. Though it has remained vacant ever since (you can check out some images of the interior taken in 2006 here), the site has undergone several renovations in the ensuing years and is both a California Historical Landmark and a National Historic Landmark. Today, it is utilized mainly as a special events venue and, of course, for filming.
Pico House has the fortunate and unique quality of boasting four rather diverse façades. As such it has proved an extremely versatile landscape for filming. The north and west edifices are both elaborately Italianate in style, with arched windows and doors and stuccoed exteriors fashioned to resemble blue granite. Though similar, the north end (pictured below) stands alone facing El Pueblo de Los Angeles’ Old Plaza and bears the look of a 19th Century courthouse or city hall . . .
. . . while the west end (pictured below), which runs along North Main Street, is much wider and is adjacent to several buildings with Victorian detailing, giving it a very San Francisco feel.
The south façade, which is situated on Arcadia Street, boasts an Old West style and has a very Sacramento-ish look.
And the east side, which runs along Sanchez Street, features fabulous red brickwork as far as the eye can see.
It is the western end that masked as Sam and Patti’s apartment building on My Sister Sam, which, as I mentioned above, was said to be located in San Francisco.
Only the exterior of the building was utilized on the series. The interior of Sam and Patti’s apartment was just a set constructed at Warner Bros. Ranch (then named The Burbank Studios Ranch), where the show was lensed.
In the Season 1 episode of Amazing Stories titled “Alamo Jobe,” which aired in 1985, the north side of Pico House masks as the site of the modern-day Alamo.
Martin Riggs (Mel Gibson) and Roger Murtaugh (Danny Glover) work patrol in front of Pico House’s north end at the beginning of 1992’s Lethal Weapon 3.
That same year, Pico House’s southern side masqueraded as Hotel Brian in 19th Century San Francisco where Lt. Commander Data (Brent Spiner) tried to secure lodging in the Season 5 episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation titled “Time’s Arrow: Part 1.”
The building situated adjacent to Pico House at 425 North Los Angeles Street also appeared as 19th Century San Francisco in the episode.
In real life, that structure (pictured below) houses the Chinese American Museum.
In the Season 1 episode of Criminal Minds titled “Machismo,” which aired in 2006, the south side of Pico House . . .
. . . . as well as the interior courtyard portrayed a police station in Allende Del Sol, Mexico.
Beginning in 2008, the south end of the site was utilized regularly as Sacramento’s CBI Headquarters on the television series The Mentalist. Besides appearing in weekly establishing shots . . .
. . . some location filming also took place on the premises, as was the case with Season 1’s “Bloodshot.”
The building’s east side was even used to portray a nightclub in that particular episode.
JLS shot their 2009 music video for “Everybody in Love” in Pico House’s courtyard. You can watch the video here.
That same year, the courtyard situated just outside of Pico House’s north entrance appeared in the “ . . . if he’s not marrying you” vignette in He’s Just Not That Into You. The bit contains one of my favorite lines from the movie – “The second you hear that, you just run to the store and get yourself some ribs and some ice cream, because you have been dumped!” You can watch the hilarious segment here.
The Ghost Adventures crew investigates paranormal happenings related to an 1871 race riot in which 19 people were killed at Pico House in the Season 4 episode titled “Pico House Hotel,” which aired in 2011.
In the 2016 drama Live by Night, Pico House’s courtyard appears as the hospital where Joe Coughlin (Ben Affleck) recovers from a beating.
The Chinese American Museum also pops up in the movie as the spot where Joe and his crew rob card players during a high stakes poker game.
For more stalking fun, follow me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Los Angeles magazine and Discover Los Angeles.
Until next time, Happy Stalking! 
Stalk It: Pico House, aka Sam and Patti’s apartment from My Sister Sam, is located at 424 North Main Street in downtown Los Angeles. The site is part of El Pueblo de Los Angeles State Historic Monument. Several areas of the monument have appeared onscreen, including the Old Plaza, located just north of Pico House at 1 Olvera Street, and the historic Olvera Street outdoor marketplace, the entrance to which is just beyond the Plaza. Union Station, another popular filming locale, can be found directly across the street at 800 North Alameda Street.
