Paul Pfeiffer’s House(s) from “The Wonder Years”

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (2 of 11)

It’s official, folks!  The Wonder Years is coming to DVD for the first time ever in October!  The 26-disc boxed set includes all six seasons of the show, plus a cast reunion segment, over 15 hours of bonus footage, a collectible metal locker, two production booklets packed with behind-the-scenes information, a replica yearbook, and Wonder Years magnets.  Sets can be pre-ordered here and there is even an option to purchase a special edition signed by Fred Savage and Danica McKellar!  Um, sign me up!  To celebrate the good news, I thought it would only be fitting to write about a Wonder Years location today – the house (or I should say “houses”) where Paul Pfeiffer (Josh Saviano) lived on the hit coming-of-age series.

[ad]

I found the address of the Pfeiffer residence on the My TWY Yearbook website and stalked it back in February.  It was not until doing research for this post, though, that I realized two different properties had actually been used to portray the family’s home on the series.  But more on that later.  The house mentioned on My TWY Yearbook was featured in the Season 5 episode of The Wonder Years titled “Pfeiffer’s Choice.”  In the episode, Paul’s family comes into some money thanks to a lucrative investment and when a jealous Jack Arnold (Dan Lauria) drives by the Pfeiffer home, with his son, Kevin Arnold (Fred Savage), he is irked to see Paul’s father, Alvin (John C. Moskoff), driving a brand new humongous John Deere tractor.

ScreenShot083

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (4 of 11)

The residence shows up a second time in the episode, in the scene in which Kevin comforts Paul after learning that Alvin has lost all of the money he recently made.

ScreenShot086

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (9 of 11)

The house used in “Pfeiffer’s Choice” can be found at 536 Tufts Avenue in Burbank, just up the street from Winnie Cooper’s (Danica McKellar) second home from the series (which I blogged about here).  The 1950-property, which boasts three bedrooms, two baths, 1,651 square feet of living space and a 0.17-acre yard, looks much the same today as it did when The Wonder Years was filmed.

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (3 of 11)

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (7 of 11)

While I was scanning through various episodes making screen captures for this post, I came across Season 6’s “Poker” and was shocked to see a different dwelling featured as Paul’s.  An address number of 537 was visible in the episode and, because most of The Wonder Years houses are situated in very close proximity to each other, I figured I would most likely find the place on University Avenue, near Kevin Arnold’s pad, which is located at 516 University.  (I blogged about it here).  Sure enough, a quick Google search of “537 University Avenue” proved my hunch correct.  Thankfully, fellow stalker Chas, of the ItsFilmedThere site, had recently taken some photographs of the residence (on account of its appearance in an episode of ER) and loaned them to me for this post.

ScreenShot089

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (2 of 3)

Why two different properties were used is anybody’s guess.  Even odder is the fact that the two Pfeiffer residences are located directly next door to each other!  (Truth be told, there might have been more properties masquerading as the Pfeiffer home over the years.  I am still only on Season 2 of my binge-watch of the series, though, so I cannot say for certain either way.)

ScreenShot091

In real life, Paul’s house from “Poker” was built in 1949 and features two bedrooms, two baths, 1,742 square feet and a 0.17-acre lot.

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (3 of 3)

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (1 of 3)

As I mentioned earlier, the same residence was also featured in an episode of ER.  It popped up in Season 4’s “Fathers and Sons” as the home of Dr. Mark Greene’s (Anthony Edwards) parents.

ScreenShot092

ScreenShot094

The real life interior of the property also appeared in the episode and, while fairly non-descript, my head just about exploded upon seeing the kitchen.

ScreenShot100

ScreenShot097

The kitchen from ER is an almost exact match to the Arnold’s kitchen from the pilot episode of The Wonder Years!  (The Wonder Years pilot made use of the actual interior of the 516 University Avenue home and, after the series got picked up, a set based on it was constructed for all subsequent filming.)

WonderYearsER

I guess the resemblance should not have come as such a surprise to me being that the two homes are located on the same street, share similar exteriors and were most likely constructed by the same builder.  I was still shocked (and delighted!) when I noticed it nonetheless.

TheWonderYearsER2

For more stalking fun, be sure to follow me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Los Angeles magazine online.  And you can check out my other blog, The Well-Heeled Diabetic, here.

Big THANK YOU to Chas, from the ItsFilmedThere website, for providing the photographs of Paul’s second house that appear in this post.

Paul Pfeiffer's House The Wonder Years (1 of 11)

Until next time, Happy Stalking!  Smile

Map of The Wonder Years Neighborhood

Stalk It: A map of The Wonder Years neighborhood is pictured above.  Paul Pfeiffer’s first house is located at 536 Tufts Avenue in Burbank.  Paul’s second house can be found next door at 537 University AvenueWinnie Cooper’s first home is located at 525 University AvenueWinnie’s second home can be found at 501 Tufts Avenue.  And Kevin Arnold’s residence is located at 516 University Avenue.

Dutton’s Brentwood Bookstore from “The Wonder Years”

UPDATE – The Wonder Years is coming to DVD for the first time ever in October!  The 26-disc boxed set includes all six seasons of the show, plus a cast reunion segment, over 15 hours of bonus footage, a collectible metal locker, two production booklets packed with behind-the-scenes information, a replica yearbook, and Wonder Years magnets.  Sets can be pre-ordered here.

Dutton's Books (2 of 7)

I recently received an extensive list of The Wonder Years filming locations from a fellow stalker named Mallory who lives in Iowa.  Mallory is a huge fan of the series (she loved it so much that she put off watching the finale for ages as she couldn’t bear to see the show end – love that!) and over the years had managed to compile an index of over thirty locales featured on it.  One of the locations, the book shop from the Season 1 episode titled “Swingers,” I had been trying to track down for a while.  Said book shop turned out to be the historic Dutton’s Brentwood Bookstore, an L.A. institution that was shuttered in 2008.  I decided the place was still worthy of a stalk, though, and headed over there when I was in the area a couple of weeks ago.

[ad]

The original Dutton’s Books & Prints was opened in 1961 by Bill and Thelma Dutton at 5146 Laurel Canyon Boulevard in North Hollywood.  All four of the couple’s children worked onsite, including eldest son Davis who took over operations of the store in the 1970s.  He opened a couple of sister shops shortly thereafter.  Doug, the youngest Dutton child, decided to establish his own branch of the family business and in 1984 purchased Brentwood Book Shop in the Barry Building, which had been around since the ‘60s.  He renamed the site Dutton’s Brentwood Bookstore and ran it independently of Davis’ outposts.  Dutton’s Brentwood was an immediate success and Doug eventually expanded, taking over several adjacent storefronts, all of which surrounded a courtyard where patrons were encouraged to lounge over a good tome.  In a 2008 Huffington Post article, author Tom Teicholz described the 5,000-square-foot space as such, “The whole place always had a ramshackle feel, with frayed carpets and crowded shelves.  Each area is its own empire, and one felt free to wander among them, and trusted to take a book from one area to the other without being accused of running off.”   The store even attracted its fare share of celebrities and such stars as Dustin Hoffman, Jamie Lee Curtis, Diane Keaton, Jennifer Garner, Ben Affleck, Meg Ryan, John Lithgow, Nora Ephron, Randy Newman, Maria Shriver, and Calista Flockhart could often be seen perusing the crowded aisles.

Dutton's Books (3 of 7)

Dutton's Books (5 of 7)

In 2004, upon learning that the owner of the Barry Building was securing plans to tear down the property to make way for a new shopping center, Doug decided to open a sister store in Beverly Hills.  He figured that if the Brentwood site did end up closing, he would still have a place to operate.  Sadly though, the Beverly Hills store wound up hurting him financially and he closed it in 2006.  Shortly thereafter, Davis shuttered the original Dutton’s in North Hollywood due to declining sales.  Dutton’s Brentwood was soon suffering the same fate and that, coupled with the fact that Doug had never recovered fiscally from the Beverly Hills debacle, led to the decision to close the store.  On April 30th, 2008, Dutton’s Brentwood made its last sale.  In a cruel twist of fate, the Barry Building’s owner eventually withdrew his plans to tear down the property in 2013.  Had Doug not opened the Beverly Hills store, it is quite possible that the Brentwood outpost would still be in operation.  Today, the space houses Cisco Home, a sustainable furniture company.

Dutton's Books (7 of 7)

Dutton's Books (1 of 7)

In the “Swingers” episode of The Wonder Years, Kevin Arnold (Fred Savage) and Paul Pfeiffer (Josh Saviano) headed to Dutton’s to pick up a copy of Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex: But Were Afraid to Ask, upon the recommendation of Kevin’s older brother, Wayne Arnold (Jason Hervey).  While the Dutton’s name was visible on the shop’s awning in the scene, because the façade of the Brentwood storefront did not match what was shown onscreen, I figured a different Dutton’s had been used in the filming.  As you can see below, the shop that appeared in The Wonder Years had an entrance door located on its right hand side.  Dutton’s (which you can see photographs of from the time that it was in operation here and here) did not.  None of the other Dutton’s locations seemed to match up either, though.  It wasn’t until Mallory mentioned that she thought a fake door had been added to the exterior for the shoot that things began to fall into place.

ScreenShot1232

Dutton's Books (4 of 7)

We now believe that a different book store was used for the interior filming and that a fake door was added to the exterior of Dutton’s so that it would match up to what was shown of that interior.

ScreenShot1233

ScreenShot1235

We still cannot figure out where interior filming took place, though.  As you can see in the scene capture below (which I flipped), there appear to be the words “Harmon Books” along with some sort of initial (possibly an “A”) painted on the door behind Kevin and Paul.  No amount of Google sleuthing has been able to unearth a Harmon Books in the L.A. area, though.  Does the store happen to look familiar to any of my fellow stalkers?

ScreenShot1240

Thanks to the Dear Old Hollywood website, I learned that the Dutton’s space was also featured in the 1965 film Sylvia, as the spot where Alan Macklin (George Maharis) first tracked down Sylvia (Carroll Baker).  At the time, the shop was still operating as the Brentwood Book Shop.

ScreenShot1239

Dutton’s North Hollywood location was the bookstore where Preston Meyers (Ethan Embry) worked in the original opening of Can’t Hardly Wait, which never made it to the screen.  That opening is only visible briefly in the movie’s trailer.

ScreenShot1237

ScreenShot1238

For more stalking fun, be sure to follow me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Los Angeles magazine online.  And you can check out my other blog, The Well-Heeled Diabetic, here.

Big THANK YOU to fellow stalker Mallory for finding this location!  Smile

Dutton's Books (6 of 7)

Until next time, Happy Stalking!  Smile

Stalk It: Cisco Home, aka the former Dutton’s Brentwood Bookstore from the “Swingers” episode of The Wonder Years, is located at 11975 San Vicente Boulevard in Brentwood.

Kevin’s House from “The Wonder Years”

UPDATE – The Wonder Years is coming to DVD for the first time ever in October!  The 26-disc boxed set includes all six seasons of the show, plus a cast reunion segment, over 15 hours of bonus footage, a collectible metal locker, two production booklets packed with behind-the-scenes information, a replica yearbook, and Wonder Years magnets.  Sets can be pre-ordered here.

Wonder Years House (19 of 19)

My good friend Mikey, from the Mike the Fanboy website, recently asked if I wanted to do some stalking of The Wonder Years house with him.  The 1968-set coming-of-age series finally made its way to Netflix in October 2011 (due to music licensing issues, it has never been released on DVD) and Mikey had been indulging in some binge-watching.  He had never stalked the Burbank-area residence where Kevin Arnold (Fred Savage) and his family – Jack (Dan Lauria), Norma (Alley Mills), Karen (Olivia d’Abo) and Wayne (Jason Hervey) –  lived on the show, though, and while I had stalked and blogged about the location before, because it was eons ago (in March 2008), I figured it was most-definitely time for a redux.  So one rainy day (I had literally just had my hair blown out, too!) a couple of weeks ago, the two of us met up to do some Wonder Years stalking.  As soon as I returned home, the Grim Cheaper and I started binge-watching the series, as well (thanks, Mikey! Winking smile), and I was shocked at how oddly sad it is – much more so than I remembered.  While still enjoyable, I find myself tearing up at least once during every episode.

[ad]

Visiting the Arnold abode was like stepping back in time.  As you can see below, virtually no part of the property has been changed in the 25-plus years since the series first debuted.

ScreenShot1081

Wonder Years House (12 of 19)

The one-story, three-bedroom, three-bath, 1,839-square-foot home, which was originally built in 1949, was featured regularly throughout the series six-season run.

ScreenShot1077

Wonder Years House (11 of 19)

Amazingly, the residence was last sold in 1987, which means that the same family who owned it during The Wonder Years years still owns it today!  Love that!

Wonder Years House (13 of 19)

Wonder Years House (18 of 19)

The dwelling was also featured weekly in The Wonder Years opening credits.

ScreenShot1072

Wonder Years House (14 of 19)

For some reason, Mikey and I were both under the mistaken impression that Winnie Cooper (Danica McKellar) waved to the camera in the opening credits and we each sat down on the curb to reenact the moment while we were there.  It was actually Paul Pfeiffer (Josh Saviano) who waved in the opening, though.  Whoops!

ScreenShot1074

Wonder Years House (15 of 19)

You can watch The Wonder Years opening credits by clicking below.  (Bet you can’t not sing along!)

Time also appears to have stood still on the Arnolds’ street.  It was never specifically stated where the series was supposed to have been set, producers instead choosing to keep things vague so that the narrative would be relatable to anyone who grew up in a suburban American town in the late 1960s.  The formula worked, too.  Even though I came of age in the ‘80s, my childhood wasn’t all that different from Kevin’s.  I cannot express how incredibly nostalgic stalking the neighborhood was – due both to the fact that it still looks like a community from a bygone era and because it brought back so many memories of my early years.

ScreenShot1078

Wonder Years House (8 of 19)

I am 99.9% certain that the real life interior of the home appeared in the pilot episode and that a set resembling it was subsequently built for all future filming once the series got picked up.  As you can see below, the kitchen in the pilot episode looks quite a bit different than than the one that appeared in the Season 1 episode titled “The Phone Call.”

WonderYearsKitchen

Another view of the kitchen from the pilot as compared to a view of the kitchen from the Season 1 episode titled “Swingers” is pictured below.

WonderYearsKitchen2

Stay tuned for Winnie Cooper’s house (pictured below) on Monday!  And I recently stumbled across this amazeballs site, so you know what that means!  There will definitely be more Wonder Years stalking in my future!

Wonder Years House (3 of 19)

For more stalking fun, be sure to follow me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Los Angeles magazine online.  And you can check out my other blog, The Well-Heeled Diabetic, here.

Big THANK YOU to Mikey, of the Mike the Fanboy website, for suggesting this stalk!  You can read his write-up of the day here.

Wonder Years House (17 of 19)

Until next time, Happy Stalking!  Smile

Stalk It: Kevin Arnold’s house from The Wonder Years is located at 516 University Avenue in Burbank.