Search for your location!

Jason Segel’s I Love You, Man House

Sep 15th, 2009 | By | Category: Movie Locations


One location I have been wanting to stalk for what seems like forever now is Jason Segel’s (aka Sydney Fife’s) Venice Beach area house and “Man Cave’” from fave movie I Love You, Man.  Fellow stalker Owen actually tracked down this location for me MONTHS ago, but since I rarely get out to the Venice area, I had yet to stalk it.  So, last weekend, my fiancé and I – armed with a notebook full of Venice area locations – finally made the pilgrimage out to L.A.’s West Side to stalk Sydney’s house.  



In I Love You, Man, Sydney Fife lives in an adorable little beach bungalow just a few steps away from the Venice Beach Boardwalk and the Pacific Ocean.  And I absolutely fell in love with the place as soon as I laid eyes on it in the movie.   But I am sad to report that the house actually looks much different in person than it did in I Love You, Man.  In fact, even though it’s hardly been a year since filming took place, had Owen not given me the address, I could have easily walked right by the home without even recognizing it.  🙁  





As you can see in the above photographs and screen captures, changes to the house include the paint color (which I actually think was a lot cuter in the movie), the addition of two sets of hedges and a new lawn to the front yard, and the removal of the cement walkway leading up to the home’s front door.  I am guessing though, that before the movie was filmed, the house looked pretty much the same as it does today and that producers made all of the above mentioned alterations solely for the filming and then returned the home to its original state after the movie was wrapped.  It sure seems like a whole bunch of work to go through, though, and makes me wonder why producers just didn’t find a different house that more closely fit their needs to use in the movie.  But that’s Hollywood for you.  🙂



While stalking the house, my fiancé and I, of course, had to go around back to check out the garage area which housed Jason Segal’s “Man Cave” in the movie.  Sadly, though, the garage has also changed considerably since the filming of I Love You, Man.  Besides the change in paint color, a new garage door and side fence have been added since the movie was filmed.

But here’s the good news!  Apparently, in real life, Jason Segel’s I Love You, Man house is not really a home at all, but a fitness center and gym named Optimum Fitness.  So, this is one stalking location that looks like it is – for the most part – open to the public!  🙂  And, best of all, if you sign up here, your first class there is free!!  🙂 


On an “Only in L.A.” side note – According to Zillow, Sidney Fife’s one bedroom, one bath house measures only 666 square feet (that’s smaller than my apartment!), yet it sold for a whopping $1,125,000 in April of 2008!  You gotta love L.A.!  🙂

Until next time, Happy Stalking!  🙂

Stalk It: Jason Segel’s house from I Love You, Man – aka Optimum Fitness gym   is located at 26 Rose Avenue in Venice.  You can visit the Optimum Fitness website and sign up for a free class here.



Leave a comment »

  1. Mary says:

    You guys: I lived in this darling bungalow on Rose Avenue in Venice Beach from 1982-1983. I rented it with 2 roommates after graduating from UC Santa Barbara, and the house was SO much cuter then! The owners at the time did a fabulous job. The cottage did have the brickwork and walkway in the front yard (as in the movie), but with two identically pruned trees planted on either side of the walkway. No heat lamps and grungy furniture like Sidney Fife’s 🙁 The cottage was painted a tasteful neutral cream color with natural dark wood window trim. The fence in the movie was the same fence. We had planter boxes with flowers on the porch, it was adorable. One day an elderly woman came up the walk to our front door and said her parents built the house in 1907! We gave her a tour and she was so glad that we had taken such good care of it. Zillow says it’s 666 sq. feet, but it feels much larger inside. There are 2 bedrooms (not one as Zillow lists) and the living room ceiling is tall. We had tons of parties; it was a wonderful location: 4 doors up from the beach. I jumped out of my seat when I first saw “I Love you, Man” with my fiance, and screamed “that was my house!!!”. I couldn’t believe it. Needless to say, I now own it. The lawn and hedge are new since the movie. I wish the owners would remove the hedge (and awful teal color) and lawn and restore it to its more tasteful past appearance. Happy New Year and I love your site! Thanks for bringing back great memories 🙂

  2. Harry Medved says:

    hey Lindsay: nice detective work – i used to work out at Optimum Fitness – but I believe it’s no longer a gym. Join us on Sunday for our Venice Beach Movie Location Tour – and you can find out more – check it out at

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

Leave a Reply